Bought a Macbook Air to replace my…iPad?

As much as I love my iPad, it had become too much of a constant source of frustration. After much thought and agonizing, I drove to the Apple store and walked out with a brand-new Macbook Air.

iPad Frustrations

Mostly, its the lack of Flash support on the iPad and the way content providers treat it differently than a regular laptop. These two things keep me from being able to watch a lot of streaming content, and many websites still haven’t yet build mobile versions or embraced HTML5.

The second big issue I have with the iPad is just the limitation of inputting *and* editing text. It’s basically a pain in the rear. If you write a lot like I do, I know you feel my pain. I considered getting one of the iPad keyboards, but it just seemed to kludgy and unbalanced.

Another issue I’ve been having with the iPad as of late, is apps constantly crashing and disappearing, particularly Evernote. It’s been really sluggish too and rebooting seems to do nothing. I’m wondering if the CPU and RAM just aren’t up to multitasking of iOS 4, remember that was the biggest upgrade in the iPad 2.

Waiting for the new Airs

I’ve been eyeing the 11″ Macbook Air for some time and waited patiently for the new models to appear. I ended up upgrading all the way to 4GB RAM, 256GB HD and Core i7 CPU. I really only wanted the larger hard drive, but the physical Apple store doesn’t carry the version with the i5 CPU. Oh well, a little speed can’t hurt.

This is the first Mac I’ve ever owned and it’s a bit of a learning curve for a long-time Windows guy. Many things are similar and many things are not. Overall, however, I’d say I like it a lot. The cross-platform nature of Chrome really makes the transition easy for browser stuff.

Transitioning from Windows

I haven’t run into any showstoppers yet. I found Mac versions or equivalents for most of the programs I truly depend on. Here are some of my positives and negatives:


  • Small size and well-balanced. The iPad in its case is actually BIGGER than the Air! Seems heavier too. Weird.
  • I love the trackpad gestures. Very smooth.
  • It is VERY fast. A coldboot takes a little over 20 seconds and that includes typing in my lengthy password! No sluggishness like you normally encounter with standard hard drives.
  • I normally don’t shutdown and just close the lid so it sleeps. Doesn’t noticably impact battery life.
  • Chrome installed with all extensions, bookmarks, etc. Incredible!
  • Magic Mouse (optional) is awesome
  • Magnetic charger connector, compact AC adapter, and extension cord are cool. This is just indicative of how far Apple thinks a product through. The AC adapter is an after-thought for all other PC manufacturers. They just use what’s already in their inventory or what the lowest bidder will give them.
  • Keyboard is useable size and keys are well-spaced. Back-lighting is great.
  • Not a huge learning curve from Windows for me.
  • Generally there are few OK buttons. You change a settings and it’s changed. Takes some getting used to, but saves a click.
  • The Microsoft Remote Desktop client works great. Lets me have a Windows machine without going through the hassle of Bootcamp.
  • Full web experience–compared to iPad’s limited one, at least in eyes of content providers :-(
  • The Windows system tray stuff is on the top-right of the screen and there is nothing at the bottom. I think I like it better.
  • I don’t miss the sluggishness and constant crashing of iPad apps.
  • Glad I waited for new Air models =)


  • Delete key acts like a Windows Backspace key. You have to hold Fn key to get equivalent of Windows Delete key.
  • I miss the middle click mouse button
  • I tried swapping the Command and Control keys in the System Prefs to make it more Windows-like, but it just made it more confusing. (Not sure why there is even a Control key.)
  • It took me a while to figure out that the menu for only the application in focus appears at the top of the screen. In Windows, each application has it’s menus at the top of it’s own window. I guess it makes sense since you can only interact with the program that’s in focus.
  • It’s weird having the close/min/max window buttons in the top-left of windows.
  • Generally everything runs in a window by default, as opposed to full screen.
  • Still getting used to switching between applications
  • Scrolling gesture is opposite direction of scrollbar drag. (I heard this was a change in Lion.)
  • Battery life isn’t even close to iPad. I probably get 2-3 hours
  • Runs a little hot, but not uncomfortably so
  • No physical button to toggle trackpad on/off, like on my HP laptop
  • Application install seems kinda kludgy. Having to sometimes manually drag the files to the Applications folder seems weird. Too easy to delete an entire application by accident.
  • Lack of VGA connector. Had to by an adapter.
  • A few utilities missing, but nothing major.

Not an Apple Fanboy!

Ok, I KNOW there is huge potential (likelihood?) of me being accused of being an Apple Fan Boy, as I sit here with my Air, iPad and iPhone 4. Does the mere ownership automatically cause me to be tarred and feathered with that label? I think not. I appreciate, understand, and continue to own several Windows machines. It’s just that right now, at this moment in time, Apple is making the best products for what I need. If the pendulum swings a different way, I’ll switch.

Not Abandoning Windows

I’ll probably continue to use my Windows desktop as a server and run some special Windows-only programs on it, but I can see that the MB Air is now my go-to portable computer. I’m going to sell my Windows 7 laptop that I bought not too long ago because I’m just not going to use it. Comparing the two is like comparing one of those early cell phones with today’s smartphones. Really.

I am waiting with interest for the Windows Ultraportable laptops (e.g., Asus X21) due out later this year. Supposedly, they are (finally) Windows’ answer to the Air (C’mon! It’s been two years!). However, you just won’t see the tight OS integration you get with the Air–there is something to say about controlling the hardware and software from A to Z. Windows will get it eventually, but I think it’s years away.

A Nice Case

I bought the perfect case for the Air at The Air fits nice and snug in the zippered pouch. The zipper goes around one corner so it’s easy to slip it in and out. There is another zippered pocket that easily holds my Magic Mouse, AC cord extension and the VGA adapter. It has both a handle, which appears very sturdy, and a removable strap. I really couldn’t ask for more.

My iPad’s Fate

What will happen to my iPad? Well, I found that I still reached for it on my nightstand for those mid-sleep computer tasks. I’m just not awake enough to use a keyboard. (Yeah, I know this is probably not a good thing to have at my fingertips at night :-) I ended up upgrading to an iPad 2 for the faster processor and memory. My original iPad is going to be used for mostly music I think. I could sell it, but it will be nice to have an extra one to just leave around an not worry about.

So Far So Good

Well, I’ve been using the Air for a solid week now and I have no regrets nor buyers remorse. I’m positive I made the right decision. I even have my Windows 7 laptop up on eBay.

Leave a Reply